Showing posts with label School/Education. Show all posts
Showing posts with label School/Education. Show all posts

Monday, June 22, 2020

Pandemic Silver Linings

The pandemic has been horrible in so many ways. Lives have been lost. Jobs and businesses have been lost. Education gaps have widened. Friends and loved ones have been isolated from one another. 

But allow me to call out a few silver linings:

Seeing Heroes: Nurses. Grocery store workers. Truck drivers. Meat packing plant workers. Farmers. Restaurant staff. The list goes on and on. The rank and file is full of under-appreciated heroes who have stepped up during this crisis. These are the heroes who are pulling us through this -- not our venerated athletes or CEOs.

Appreciating Missing Critical People: Many parents now have much better understanding of what every teacher deals with every day. What about people who clean houses and cut hair and so many other tasks that we value, but were put on hold? During the lockdown, we have been living the old adage that you don't properly value what you have until it is taken away from you.

BLM: George Floyd wasn't the first. Black and brown people have been victims of police brutality before, so why did these protests really gain traction? I think we can thank the pandemic. 
  1. Logistics: Traffic is light and parking is easy. 
  2. Free Time: Movie theaters and gyms and most other athletic/entertainment venues are closed. Plus, unemployment is around 20%.
  3. No Distractions: There are no sports or new movies or other distractions to replace it in the news cycle. The BLM movement is flourishing in the open space created by the pandemic.
Inspiring Change: The wheels of progress in education grind incredibly slowly. The pandemic has the potential to add a big jolt of innovation as schools and educators try to figure out how to make virtual and blended learning work. I imagine that necessity is driving innovation in other areas as well. 

Seeing Flaws in Our Systems: People who depend on their low-paying jobs for their healthcare are either showing up when sick (e.g., Smithfield plant) or losing health coverage. Many CEOs and Presidents and other leaders have made it explicitly clear that they care more about money than they do about the health of the people who toil to enrich them. The pandemic is a stressor that helps us see the flaws in our systems. It doesn't point the way to fixing them, but understanding that something is broken is the first step.

None of these silver linings provide succor to those who have lost loved ones or businesses or jobs or security or comfort. As a society, I am hopeful that we will make changes to our mindsets, relationships, and systems so the legacy of the pandemic will include some good outcomes.

Friday, June 5, 2020

Higher Ed Reopening Decisions

A lot is going on right now, so I'll spew forth some ideas on various topics in the coming weeks. I've chosen this topic partly because it is relatively easy for me to be dispassionate about it. I am intellectually interested and only somewhat impacted. There are more important things going on in the US, but this is where I'm starting.

As colleges and universities around the country weigh how they will reopen this Fall, various voices are being heard. Here are just two:
What are some of the factors that schools are weighing (whether they admit them or not)?

Faculty and staff: Students are generally young and have few preexisting conditions. On the other hand, faculty and staff are older, and many have family members with significant risks. Bringing students back puts the faculty, staff, business owners, and all their families at risk. Honestly, this seems like an OSHA issue to me.

Revenue: When I originally looked at the university bill I paid in January, I just focused on the bottom line: How much am I writing a check for? Now, I look at every line and wonder: Will there be an athletic fee if the gym is closed? What about the meal plan? If everything were virtual, the bottom line would be VERY different. For me, all of those are distinct costs, but for the university, they are all important revenue streams.

The higher education value proposition: I'm not going to wade too far into the "is college worth it" debate, but I found this article by Susan Svrluga at the Washington Post particularly interesting: Is college worth it? A Georgetown study measures return on investment — with some surprising results. One thing this points out is that not all schools (even within a particular university) are equal financially. Most vocational schools such as law and business and engineering will survive this regardless. Those departments that can go virtual well probably should. But what about schools of liberal arts? What about those philosophy and religious studies and sociology departments? They are in a tougher spot. Faculty in these areas care about their health, but they also like having jobs. Honestly, this probably requires its own blog posts, but what if I just go with word association: community colleges, gap year, University of Phoenix, the humanities make us human.

Students without privilege: Many students are barely able to afford college. They scrape by thanks to on-campus jobs and scholarships and loans. This upheaval will make the college dream unattainable for many of these students. Without a job in the dining hall or at the athletic center, some students can't afford to live on campus. On the other hand, some students have home lives that aren't compatible with distance learning. Internet access, child care, loud siblings, space, and a plethora of other issues make virtual learning virtually impossible for many students. It's a lose-lose proposition for them.

College towns: There is no Blacksburg without Virginia Tech. What about Ann Arbor without the Univeristy of Michigan? Oberlin, OH? College Station, TX? State College, PA? You get the idea. Hechinger Report has Little-noticed victims of the higher education shutdowns: college towns

Students with privilege: First of all, I have put students last because they (as a population) are not particularly at risk, and they are resilient. If they all had to live at home and do this virtually, most of them would figure out how to do it well. That said, I'm sure my son is not alone in wanting very desperately to get back to campus (I'm trying not to be hurt). 

Let's be honest and admit that faculty and schools come at this from radically different perspectives. Faculty care about the health of their families, while schools are confronting an existential crisis. Many schools probably worry that going virtual will crush their bottom line, degrade the educational experience, and open themselves up to competition from challengers they never had to worry about before. 

So... what should schools do? 
  1. No school or jurisdiction should open without a solid test-trace-isolate strategy. This May 15 article by Alex Tabarrok and Puja Ahluwalia Ohlhaver at The Washington Post: We could stop the pandemic by July 4 if the government took these steps lays out solid strategies.
  2. Blended Learning: The importance of this is two-fold: Blending can help reduce class sizes (which improves safety), and can help prepare for going to more virtual strategies. 
  3. Flexibility: How will you deal with a surge in cases on campus? How will you re-imagine your traditional gatherings? 
Should be interesting to see how this plays out.

Tuesday, October 13, 2009

I Love Monty Hall

OK, so I don't really love Monty. What I love is the problem that is named for him, which can be stated as follows:
You are a contestant on Let's Make a Deal. Monty has given you a choice of three doors. Behind two doors are goats, but one door has a nice, shiny new red car with a radio! You choose a door. Monty (who knows what is behind each door) then reveals that behind one of the other doors is a goat. He then he asks you: Do you want to switch to the other door, or do you want to stay with your original choice?

The question for you is: Should you stay with your original choice, switch doors, or does it not matter?
If you haven't before, stop and think about the problem before reading on.

Coding Horror has an article: Monty Hall, Monty Fall, Monty Crawl that a friend from work sent to me recently. I agree with the Jeff Atwood, who says:
What's interesting about this problem, to me at least, is not the solution, but the vehemence with which people react to the solution....
Here is a nice, simple explanation of the correct answer courtesy of Antonio Cangiano at Zen and the Art of Programming:
When you make your first choice your probability of winning the car is only 1/3. If you decide to switch, you will win only if the first choice you made was wrong. And since your first choice came with a 2 out of 3 chance of picking a goat, switching will then (logically) give you 2/3 chance of winning.
But don't believe me. Check out these sites:
Anyway, this is a great problem.

Tuesday, June 17, 2008

TJ Graduation: Video, Reminiscence, Beach Balls, and Rickrolling

I attended Niece 2's graduation from The Thomas Jefferson High School for Science and Technology (AKA TJ) this weekend. It was fun. Here are some thoughts on the ceremony.

Video: Niece 2 is being filmed for a documentary about college admissions, so through most of the ceremony, she had a film crew following her around. It was pretty funny. They filmed as she walked in. They filmed as she walked back to sing with the choir, then as she sang, and as she walked back to her normal seat with the graduates. They filmed her as she sat listening to the proceedings. The upside was that it made it easier to find her after the ceremony. We could just look for the boom mic and the video camera.

Reminiscence: I used to teach at TJ, so I know some of the teachers and enjoyed seeing them. One Math/Computer Science teacher in particular, who also taught me Geometry and Computer Science when I was in high school, was a tremendous teacher. He's retiring this year and I'm happy for him, but sad for TJ.

Beach Balls: Every once in a while, some kids would start knocking a beach ball around before some teacher or security person got a hold of it. I understand that the teachers don't want the kids to be rude to the speakers and to preserve some sense of decorum, but I also understand the kids who are barely holding in their elation. I feel like the beach balls should come out every once in a while, bounce around, then be put away.

The last student speaker had a short, funny speech that ended with him saying:
I'm never gonna give you up, never gonna let you down
Never gonna run around and desert you
Never gonna make you cry, never gonna say goodbye
Never gonna tell a lie and hurt you
I love that he rickrolled the entire Patriot Center.

The bottom line is that we are all so incredibly proud of Niece 2 and her ability to make it through high school while dealing with more serious issues than most of us can imagine. Actually, she didn't just "make it through," she excelled in the face of adversity and that's really remarkable. After this, I have little doubt that she will kick major butt when she heads to college.

Soundtrack: Gorillaz (Demon Days and their eponymous first album)

Tuesday, June 10, 2008

D&D Still Lives: Who Knew?

D&D 4th Edition is coming out. I had no idea D&D still existed. [edit: More accurately, I knew people still played it, but for me, D&D is still represented by the AD&D Dungeon Master's Guide circa 1979. The idea that the game would have evolved after I last played it in 1984 never occurred to me.]

When I was in college, Dungeons and Dragons (AKA D&D) and Traveller (a similar game set in outer space) were really fun, creative outlets for us. The man who ran our D&D world and the one who ran the Traveller universe were incredibly creative. They created experiences that were akin to participating in creating a series of stories with a bunch of good friends.

Because I was in school with a bunch of people who knew science better than the average person, our D&D world and Traveller universe had rules that were different from the official versions. Our spaceships accelerated, decelerated, and maneuvered in ways that were at least somewhat consistent with the laws of physics. People took damage (had injuries) in ways that made biological sense. Technology progressed over time so that if you had technology that could help you hide from or find your enemies, it wouldn't be effective forever. In our Traveller universe, there was a rich technological and political environment.

Any time I hear about D&D, I think about "Flow" (Kevin Oliveau who ran the Traveller Universe and then founded a cohousing community) and "Noqui" (the late, great Karl Horita who ran the D&D world.) I haven't played anything like D&D or Traveller for 24 years, but I still have fond memories of the stories they let me participate in.

Thursday, April 10, 2008

Picasso Versus Cezanne

The keynote at this year's NCTM conference in Salt Lake City was a talk by Malcolm Gladwell who was really good. His big theme was about the dichotomy between explosive genius (as personified by Pablo Picasso) and long-term, patient genius (as personified by Cezanne). Picasso did his most valuable work in his mid-twenties while Cezanne didn't peak until his 50's or 60's. It's not really a matter of being a late bloomer. It's about a different approach. One way is a flash of brilliance that is a great, fully-formed idea (Picasso-esque), while the other is achieved by slow, persistent change over a great deal of time (Cezanne-esque). In this talk, Gladwell has borrowed and expanded a bit on an idea by economist David Galenson (here is a synopsis of Galenson's findings.)

Gladwell has given this talk other times, so kurup.org has a synopsis and review of an earlier iteration of the talk. Here is the list of Picasso vs. Cezanne types I wrote down during the talk:

Picasso-esque
  • Melville (wrote Moby Dick in a year when he was 32, then not much else of note)
  • The Eagles (their fifth album was the huge hit Hotel California, after which they only put out one more)
  • GM/Ford/Chrysler (many innovations, but rarely persistent)
  • American math (students give up when answers don't come easily)
Cezanne-esque
  • Mark Twain (wrote Huck Finn when 49. It took him over seven years to write it.)
  • Fleetwood Mac (Rumours was their 16th album!)
  • Japanese automakers (persisted for 20 years in engineering hybrids)
  • Asian math (persistent test takers)
Some things I took from the NCTM version of Gladwell's talk:
  • The folks who give the big international math test on which Western students get crushed by the Asian students (TIMMS) decided to put a questionaire at the beginning. There were a ton of questions and many students simply gave up. When you rank countries by how many questions their students answered in the pre-test (ungraded) questionaire, it turns out to look almost exactly like the list of how the countries did on the actual test. Implication: It's all about persistence. Asian students don't give up, but American and other western students do.
  • The implication with the artists is that they stopped being any good after their popular successes. Rather, I think some of the great ones (e.g., Picasso and Melville) simply became advanced.
Anyway, it was an interesting talk and many of the ideas are worth exploring.

Monday, April 7, 2008

My Life in Music: Grad School

It's been a long time since my earlier My Life in Music posts. I started with Undergrad, Take 1, then went on to Undergrad, Take 2. Now for grad school.

Grad School went from the end of 1986 to May of 1988. These are the albums that defined that time for me:

The Pretty in Pink soundtrack helps define some of the music we listened to at the college radio station where I was the Program Director at the beginning of grad school. WGMU (motto: The Only Station That Matters) was lots of fun. We had an incredibly small audience, but had a really great time.

New Order's Substance is the music that I think of when I think of the (now defunct) Tracks nightclub in southeast DC. I will have to create an entry on Tracks sometime. It was a truly incredible place.


Fishbone's eponymous EP was a fun sing along album. Tunes like Party at Ground Zero and U.G.L.Y were fun, but when girls were causing us grief, we liked to yell along with Lyin' Ass Bitch.


Beelzebubba (by The Dead Milkmen), Aliens Ate My Buick (by Thomas Dolby), and Album (by Public Image Limited) were just really fun albums I listened to many, many times. Tracks like Bleach Boys, My Brain Is Like a Sieve, and Rise were common accompaniments to my studies.

Thursday, January 17, 2008

My Life in Music: Undergrad, Take 1

This is the first of a series of posts about the albums that were the soundtracks of my college years.

It took me a couple tries to get college right. The years 1982-1984 were in part defined by these albums.
  • Urgh! A Music War
  • Brian Eno, Another Green World and Ambient 3 or anything else ambient
  • Walter Carlos (now Wendy Carlos), Switched on Bach
  • U2, War
  • Berlioz, Symphonie Fantastique
  • Mannheim Steamroller (Fresh Aire, Fresh Aire II, Fresh Aire III, and Fresh Aire IV)
  • Jean-Michel Jarre (Oxygene, Equinoxe, Magnetic Fields)
Dan "Mad Dog" Dougherty was one of my pledge brothers at Epsilon Theta. He had the most amazing record collection I have ever seen. It was notable not just for its size (which was impressive), but also for its diversity and quality. He had some really amazing music. One album that struck my ear was Urgh! A Music War. It turns out that it was a soundtrack for a movie that I finally saw sometime last year. It is a concert movie with an amazingly diverse list of performers including The Police, The Go-Go's, XTC, Devo, The Dead Kennedys, and Steel Pulse to name but a few. These are really energetic performances from the apex of the new wave and punk movements. Some performances are bizarre, but many are really full of incredible energy. I just realized that this movie deserves a post all to its own, so I will move on to the next album....

When I studied, I often turned to Dan's collection of ambient music. Brian Eno is the father of ambient music, but he's done lots of other stuff as well. Ambient 3 is actually by Laraaji, but was produced by Eno. It is incredibly subtle (i.e., repetitive) music that I suspect few people can really appreciate. It probably says something scary about me that I like it, but such is life.

Walter Carlos worked with Moog on the original synthesizers. He produced lots of interesting purely electronic music. He did the soundtrack for A Clockwork Orange, but I still remember him primarily for his/her electronic versions of Bach's work. Later, he had a sex change and is now Wendy.

In the summers of '82 and '83 I worked for Bell Labs. The latter year was in New Jersey and my favorite song was New Years Day by U2. That song still reminds me of boring evenings in my apartment on Rutgers' Bush campus in Piscataway.

A couple pledge siblings (Epsilon Theta is co-ed) and I took a music appreciation class (was 21.600, but now is 21M.011) together. I don't remember everything that Lowell Lindgren taught us, but I remember that on the final, we had to name the work, composer, year, place, etc. for a bunch of sound snippets he played for us. One of the snippets was from Symphonie Fantastique. Here is Wikipedia's description of the end of the fourth movement (from which our snippet was taken):

"The scene ends with a single short fortissimo G-minor chord that represents the fatal blow: the dropping of the trap door, or perhaps the guillotine blade; the series of pizzicato notes following can be seen to represent the rolling of the severed head into the basket."

What a wonderful symphony.

A bunch of us were into music that later would be called New Age. Jarre and Mannheim Steamroller were staples. we'd play them quietly (usually with headphones) when studying, but we'd crank some Jarre when cleaning the house or when having a "stereo war" before 24-hour quite time around final exam time. This is Noqui's sound and anything that reminds me of one of my favorite people of all time is a good thing.

Anyway, this is the music that defined my first stint in college. I still listen to Eno and Berlioz and some U2, but most of the rest of it is just for when I am feeling nostalgic. This is the soundtrack of a world completely removed from influence by popular culture. The independence and purity still make me smile.

The Day
  • Workout: short run
  • Music: Cake, Crystal Method, Dave Brubeck Quartet

Wednesday, December 19, 2007

Study Then Sleep

I just thought about an old post by Ze Frank today. He is a really interesting guy and has some interesting ideas for how to study then sleep.

Many people with whom I went to college tried to stay up late drinking coffee to study for big tests. Then, when it was time for the test, they choked. Why? My brother suggested that the reason was state-dependent learning. When the mind learns, the information is trapped in a brain in a certain state. If the brain is tired or on caffeine or on some other drug, then that information is in a brain in that state. If you don't re-create that state for the test, then you could be in for an ugly surprise.

My strategy (based on my brother's ideas) was to listen to the same album over and over while studying. Picking the album for a semester took some effort. I needed to really like the album because I would be listening to it over and over for the following week or two. There was considerable diversity in my choices. I used Charlie Brown Christmas, Rachmaninoff, Rush, Joe Jackson, and others. Once I picked the album, I would listen to it repeatedly while at home.

When I went into the final, I had all the music (and thus all the knowledge) right there in my mind. No need for an iPod (good thing since they were over a decade from existing) because I had heard the album over and over again and had it resonating in every fiber of my being. I could just summon the music and along with it came the information I needed.

Most people in my family are too smart for these sorts of tricks. They did crazy stuff like keep up with their work all semester, but for me, this sort of thing worked well. Final exams almost always brought my grade up a letter at the end.

Anyway, I know this is probably too late (in some cases many years too late) for most who are reading this post, but I thought I'd share. You never know who might need to take a test of some sort.

The Renovation
Yesterday Herb (the electrician) and Doug (the GC) came back to fix some wiring and paint the siding where the sliding glass door used to be. Today, Doug came back to install the last upper cabinet doors and shelves as well as the last lower cabinet drawers. He is still waiting on the little fake drawer that goes in front of the sink.

The Day

Tuesday, December 18, 2007

The Joy and Pain of Kisses

Here is something from Niece II (a follow-up to A College Acceptance to Be Proud of):

"...My English teacher got so excited [about Niece II's acceptance to PWC] he JUMPED and then threw Hershey Kisses at me and the rest of the class. Then he said he always feels awkward congratulating people this time of year because "there's always some kid who was certain that they were going to get into MIT and is totally heartbroken because they got rejected." A girl in the back of the room burst into tears on the spot; she was that kid. It was both sad and hilarious. Everyone felt awkward but he kept throwing candy."

I used to teach at that school and I know how her teacher feels. So often kids get attached to the idea of one particular school being perfect for them that they are devastated when they don't get in. You can't tell this kid that there are other great schools any more than you can tell a fifteen-year old boy who has had his girlfriend leave him for the captain of the football team that she is a tramp and there are other fish in the sea.

The pain can seem irrational or unimportant to an outsider, but it is very real. I really think that every kid who is applying to schools needs to understand that it's always a matter of some luck. Even the most perfect kid isn't guaranteed admission to every school, so if you get fixated on one in particular, there is a real chance that you will be disappointed. Taking a shot with early decision is great, but if you don't get into the school of your dreams, apply to a range of schools at which you could be happy.

College can be an incredible experience. Even if you don't get in to the school of your dreams, you can still get into a school that is really good for you. When it comes right down to it, college is more about what you do than it is about what college you attend. You can do great things after (and even while) attending a small state school or you could do nothing great after attending the finest institutions in the country. You have to accept responsibility for who you will become and not simply give some person or institution the blame or credit.

I know this seems like it's written to a senior in high school, but 1) I hope Niece II and Niece III read this and 2) all adults who might come in contact with a junior or senior in high school should think about this sort of thing so we can provide some sage advice to these kids. OK, maybe not sage advice, but not putting your foot in your mouth or saying something that results in the kid being miserable doesn't seem like such a lofty goal. BTW: I will write about college majors in a later post.

Enjoy the Hershey's Kisses.

The Day